Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
49 Years
experience
Custom Handcrafted Furniture in Libertyville, IL
Since 1977, O'Reilly's Furniture & Amish Gallery has been dedicated to providing high-quality, handcrafted furniture that stands the test of time. Our expertise lies in creating custom solid wood furniture tailored to individual preferences, allowing customers to select styles, woods, finishes, and dimensions that perfectly suit their homes. We also specialize in premium upholstery through partnerships with renowned American brands like England Furniture, Omnia Leather, and Smith Brothers of Berne, offering thousands of fabric and leather options. Our Libertyville showroom showcases an extensive selection of dining sets, bedroom furniture, home office solutions, and living room pieces, all crafted with meticulous attention to detail.

Under new ownership since 2018, we continue Gary O'Reilly's legacy of exceptional customer service and community connection while maintaining our commitment to Amish craftsmanship. Our team guides clients through every step of the customization process, ensuring each piece becomes a cherished heirloom. With over four decades of experience, we pride ourselves on delivering unmatched quality at accessible prices, treating every customer like family while upholding the values that have sustained us since our founding.
Services
Custom Dining Sets Amish Bedroom Sets Upholstery Selection Home Office Furniture Occasional Tables Entertainment Centers
Details
  • Year established: 1977
Highlights and features
  • We offer 45+ years of expertise in custom furniture craftsmanship
  • Our Amish artisans create heirloom-quality, fully customizable wood furniture
  • We partner with premium American upholstery brands like Smith Brothers
  • Our family-owned business maintains Gary O'Reilly's original commitment to quality
  • We provide personalized design assistance for complete home furnishing solutions
What people say
Quality and value Outstanding service Helpful sales staff Perfect fit for home Lasting investment
Services
Custom Dining Sets
Handcrafted Amish dining tables and chairs made from solid wood with full customization options. Customers choose wood species, dimensions, finishes, and design details to create unique dining spaces. Built to last generations with traditional joinery techniques.
Amish Bedroom Sets
Complete bedroom collections featuring handcrafted beds, dressers, and nightstands using time-tested Amish construction methods. Available in multiple wood types and finishes with customizable sizing to fit any bedroom layout.
Upholstery Selection
Premium upholstery options from England Furniture, Omnia Leather, and Smith Brothers of Berne. Over 1,200 fabric and leather choices available for custom sofas, sectionals, and chairs with personalized configurations and lifetime warranties.
Home Office Furniture
Custom-built desks, bookcases, and office storage solutions crafted from solid wood. Designed for functionality and durability with options for wood species, finishes, and dimensional specifications to create productive workspaces.
People
Gary O'Reilly
Founder
Founded the business in 1977 with a commitment to quality furniture and exceptional customer service. Built lasting community relationships through personalized attention to customer needs and Amish craftsmanship.
Mike Walsh
Owner
Took ownership in 2018 while preserving the original family business values. Maintains connections with Amish craftsmen to ensure heirloom-quality furniture production and continues Gary O'Reilly's customer service legacy.
Questions
How does the furniture customization process work?
Our design consultants guide you through selecting wood types, dimensions, finishes, and details for Amish pieces, or fabric/leather options for upholstery to create personalized furniture solutions.
What upholstery brands do you offer?
We feature England Furniture, Omnia Leather, and Smith Brothers of Berne with thousands of fabric and leather choices for custom sofas, sectionals, and chairs.
Is all furniture made in the USA?
Yes, all wood furniture is handcrafted by Amish artisans in America while our upholstery partners maintain US manufacturing facilities with lifetime warranty coverage.
Do you offer delivery services?
We provide professional delivery and setup services for all furniture purchases within our service area with white-glove handling of custom pieces.
What's your return policy?
Custom-made furniture cannot be returned, but we guarantee satisfaction through our quality craftsmanship and will resolve any issues with purchased items.
Reviews (7)
Beth Koehn
Jul 28, 2021 Report
I am thrilled with the console table we had custom made. The piece is exactly what I wanted and extremely well made. The sales staff at the store were wonderful. We have other pieces of furniture we are still looking to get and I will be more than happy to give my money to a local business.
Kate A.
May 24, 2021 Report
Best furniture shopping and delivery experience I've ever had! Friendly, knowledgable owner and staff. Superior customer service. Meticulous delivery and in-home setup. High quality furniture. I can't imagine getting furniture anywhere else now. I've been disappointed so many times shopping at chain stores. In a world of sub-par customer experiences, it's refreshing to find a place like O'Reilly's just down the street. I will be a repeat customer for sure. Thank you again!!
Wendy Wu
May 20, 2021 Report
The owner, Mike, and his associate, Pat, were absolutely pleasant to work with. Very patient and educating at the same time without being overbearing. We bought our furniture mid-COVID from these lovely people and theyve been very transparent about the COVID-delays and process. The store offers a wide selection of quality products, really nice wood, and a huge selection of fabrics - more than many of the other furniture stores Ive visited. If you ever find a quality product, run it through with Mike and see if he has it in stock as well. Hes the small family business youd enjoy working
Andrea Kruger
Feb 01, 2021 Report
Best customer service for some furniture we purchased here at O'Reilly's. Mike, the owner and his delivery team took wonderful care of us and gave us fantastic pricing. We will continue to purchase from them in the future as they stand by what they sell. Hands down best quality and pricing in the area! Thanks so much!
Marley Lunt
Jun 05, 2020 Report
Hands down my favorite furniture store!!! I ordered a custom Amish dinning room table and chairs and they turned out beautiful. Mike was very helpful and patient as I took a few months to figure out the exact look I wanted. They can order pretty much any look you want and do a great job finding the best price with the many vendors they work with.
Kaitlin Walsh
Dec 04, 2019 Report
Purchased a small dining set and and a few other items, by far the sturdiest furniture Ive ever owned. Compliments every time we have guests over on the look and quality. Excellent delivery service as well.
Adam Stokes
Jul 27, 2018 Report
Very happy with our first purchase from O'Reilly's! Everyone was easy to work with, our couch was ready right when we were told it would be, and they were able to deliver the same day it arrived in their store. They even disposed of our old couch for us! We looked at at least half a dozen furniture shops, and they were the only one selling the high quality we wanted. We already have plans for a few more future purchases.