Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
33 Years
experience
Your Trusted Custom Home Builder in Northeast Ohio
Founded in 1993, Payne & Payne Builders has established itself as a premier custom home builder in Northeast Ohio. Our approach combines decades of industry experience with award-winning business practices to deliver exceptional living experiences tailored to each client's unique vision. We prioritize treating every client like family, ensuring every home is built to the same exacting standards we would apply to our own properties. With a proven process refined over 30 years, we specialize in transforming dream homes into reality through personalized design, transparent communication, and uncompromising craftsmanship.

Our team's expertise spans from land acquisition and architectural design to construction and post-warranty support, making us a trusted lifelong resource for homeowners. We maintain strong relationships with top-tier tradespeople and suppliers to guarantee superior quality while offering competitive pricing. Our commitment to excellence has earned national recognition and sustained growth through client referrals, reflecting our core philosophy: build meaningful relationships and deliver homes that exceed expectations.
Services
Custom Home Building Quick Move-In Homes Land Acquisition Services Design-Build Process Post-Warranty Support Architectural Design Client Consultations Community Development Home Personalization Construction Management
Details
  • Year established: 1993
Highlights and features
  • We offer 30+ years of custom home building experience since 1993
  • Our award-winning business practices ensure superior value for clients
  • We provide exclusive access to off-market properties through industry partnerships
  • Our proven four-step process guarantees transparency and quality control
  • We maintain lifelong client relationships beyond warranty period support
What people say
Exceeded expectations Unparalleled craftsmanship Transparent communication Personalized service Lifelong support
Services
Custom Home Building
Our custom home building service transforms client visions into reality through personalized design and construction. We collaborate closely with homeowners to create energy-efficient, high-quality residences tailored to their lifestyle needs. With over three decades of experience, we ensure every detail meets our exacting standards while maintaining budgetary control.
Quick Move-In Homes
These ready-to-build or partially completed homes offer accelerated timelines for clients seeking immediate occupancy. Available across multiple Northeast Ohio communities, they combine luxury features with customizable options before final construction phases, providing premium living solutions without extended wait periods.
Land Acquisition
We assist clients in finding ideal building lots through extensive industry partnerships. Our services include evaluating existing properties for development potential and connecting clients with exclusive on- and off-market land opportunities that match their specific location and lifestyle requirements.
Design-Build Process
Our streamlined design-build methodology unifies architectural design and construction phases under one team. This approach ensures cohesive project execution from concept to completion, reducing timelines while maintaining design integrity and cost efficiency through centralized project management.
Post-Warranty Support
Beyond standard warranty periods, we continue providing maintenance guidance and support for homeowners. This ongoing assistance reflects our commitment to long-term client relationships, offering peace of mind and continued value preservation for properties we've built.
People
F. Michael Payne
Founder
With nearly three decades in residential construction, including leadership roles in major home-building companies, Mike established Payne & Payne Builders in 1993. His hands-on approach and industry expertise continue to shape the company's standards.
Dave Payne
Co-Owner
Joining shortly after the company's founding, Dave brought extensive construction experience that helped scale operations. He maintains active involvement in daily operations and quality control processes across all projects.
Questions
What areas do Payne & Payne Builders serve?
We primarily serve Northeast Ohio, including communities like Barrington, Canyon Ridge, Walden, Moreland Commons, and Kirtland Tudor Estates.
What home types do you offer?
We specialize in custom-built luxury homes and quick move-in opportunities with personalized design options available before completion.
How does your building process work?
Our four-stage process includes discovery/design, pre-construction planning, construction with regular updates, and lifelong post-warranty support for homeowners.
Can you help find building land?
Yes, we partner with land developers and real estate agents to help clients locate ideal properties, both on and off the market.
What makes Payne & Payne different?
Our family-owned business combines 30+ years of experience with award-winning practices, treating every client like family while maintaining strict quality control.
Do you offer financing options?
We recommend connecting with preferred lenders who understand our building process, though specific financing arrangements are handled through third-party institutions.
Reviews (6)
Suzanne Turle
Nov 17, 2020 Report
The professionals at Payne and Payne guided us through every step of the process and we were kept informed of what was happening with our house. We were given a schedule at the beginning of the build and the house remained on schedule and was completed by the scheduled date. They worked very hard to stay within our budget. When we made changes and additions they were very careful to give us the prices of additions.
Communications was great. Calls were returned promptly. Buildertrend was a great help in communication. We were amazed at how clean the work site was kept. Floors were swept daily
Bob Littell
Nov 12, 2020 Report
Everyone with whom we came in contact was very committed to delivering exceptional value and making the experience satisfying in all respects. When asking for advice, recommendations, etc. as a novice new home buyer, everyone was very constructive and considerate of our budget, concerns, needs, etc. This did a lot to establish and sustain credibility and trust. Honest answers that considered an array of experiences by our primary contacts. Would (and have already) recommend them to anyone! BTW, after considerable time in the new home, would not change a thing! Further testimony to our level of
Andrew Holpuch
Oct 12, 2020 Report
We would build again and again with Payne and Payne. The process from design to completion was organized and timely. Their response time was phenomenal - any questions or changes were typically addressed within hours. They were accommodating to changes along the way and offered their expert opinion to improve the layout and design of our home. Ultimately, I got the impression that they built our house as if it was their own. We are proud to call this house our home!
Edward Waters
Aug 25, 2020 Report
I have recommended Payne and Payne many times since the process began on building our new home. The follow thru now that our home is complete has been incredible. I would absolutely use them again and appreciate all that they accomplished for me and my family. Thank you Payne and Payne!
Pam Pierce
Aug 01, 2020 Report
Initially, I was very impressed, and I've seen a lot of builders' work since I inspect new homes. I would not hesitate to recommend one of their standard pre-built homes, it is high quality compared to most builders. When a friend needed to build a new home I interviewed many builders. Unlike most, this company was willing to customize the home, had quality building practices due to using the same few quality contractors for all their homes, said they supervised their work, and had a decent price (not the lowest and way below the highest). The sales person was amazing, and so is the supervisor
Foxwood Mentor
Jul 20, 2020 Report
We had very high expectations for Payne & Payne, which were exceeded. The standard of excellence and communication are big differentiators. As always, it's about the people. P&P have excellent people who are total professionals. We asked lots of questionsand plenty of advice. Without bias, P&P vetted our many questionsand offerred recommendations to consider. I think we took all the advice given.

When we wanted to explore things like closed cell insulation or sourcing a craftsman to make copper roofs, they were there to sort it out for us. P&P invited collaboration and delivered great results.